March 10, 2026
Just Wars and This War
Author
An unwise and unwarranted conflict

We woke up Saturday morning to discover that we are at war with Iran. How should Christians think about this turn of events? Over time, theologians developed criteria to determine whether a war was just or unjust:
1. The cause must be just.
2. The intentions must be just.
3. War must be a last resort.
4. The war must be declared by a legitimate authority.
5. There must be a reasonable chance of success.
6. The violence must be proportional to the desired outcome.
Here are my thoughts about the conflict that erupted over the weekend in light of each criterion.
1. I agree with many Christian ethicists that self-defense is the only just cause for waging war. While U.S. and Iranian forces have targeted each other on and off for decades, there is no evidence that an Iranian attack against the U.S. or one of its treaty allies was imminent.
2. It is hard to know whether our intentions are just because the administration has offered multiple and conflicting rationales for this war. Within hours after the attacks began, the President called for the Iranian people to rise up and overthrow their rulers. A few days later, the Secretary of Defense denied that regime change was the goal of this war. Administration officials have offered many other reasons for this war, including avenging American deaths at the hands of Iranian agents, destroying Iran’s nuclear and ballistic missile programs, and destroying the Iranian navy to protect Persian Gulf sea lanes. Are we fighting for all these reasons?
3. This war is not a last resort. On Friday, the Foreign Minister of Oman announced that a breakthrough had occurred during Omani-mediated negotiations between the U.S. and Iran on the future of Iran’s nuclear program. The next day, the President ordered an attack on Iran. Why resort to war at the very moment when diplomacy was yielding results?
4. Last week, the President gave the longest State of the Union address in American history, but he devoted just one paragraph to Iran. Four days later, he ordered the largest military attack in a generation. He started this war without seeking Congressional approval, which the Constitution requires, or making the case for war to the public. For a war to be just, Congress and the American people must weigh in first.
5. Because the intentions of this war are unclear, it is hard to know whether this war has a reasonable chance of success. The U.S. military is more than a match for the Iranians, but if our goal is to make Iran a free country, it will take much more than airpower alone to succeed.
6. Unlike the unjust war that Russia is waging against Ukraine, the United States is not launching indiscriminate attacks that kill and injure civilians. The tragic bombing of a school near an Iranian military facility on Saturday appears to be just that, a tragedy, not a war crime. Because these types of tragedies are almost guaranteed in modern warfare, it is essential that war is only waged when the above criteria are met.
I shed no tears for the Ayatollah Ali Khamenei or his ruthless Revolutionary Guards. They have oppressed the Iranian people for decades and killed thousands of protestors in January. My prayer is that one day Iran will be a freer country that lives in peace with its neighbors near and far. Perhaps this war will hasten that day. I hope so. But if that happens, it will not be because this war is just or wise, but because God is sovereign over nations. God can bend the crooked paths we walk toward God’s intent to bless all nations of the world.






