April 20, 2026
Rendering Unto Caesar
Author
What Christians owe their governments
Tax Day has come and gone. Hooray! Hopefully you either received a refund or had to render only a small amount to Caesar.
“Render unto Caesar,” is from the Bible (Mark 12:17, KJV). When Jesus was teaching in the temple, his enemies asked him a gotcha question. “Is it lawful to pay taxes to the emperor or not?” A “Yes” answer would anger the crowds. They hated paying taxes to their Roman occupiers. A “No” answer would expose him to the charge of fomenting insurrection.
Jesus asked his opponents to produce a coin. “Whose face is that?” he asked them. “The emperor’s,” they replied. Jesus said, “Give to the emperor the things that are the emperor’s, and to God the things that are God’s.” Jesus avoided their trap with an enigmatic answer.
But what did he mean? Some commentators have focused, not on the meaning of Jesus’s saying, but on how deftly Jesus handled bad faith conversation partners. The lesson for his disciples is, don’t feed the trolls. Throw their trick questions back on them.
More interpretations run along these lines: coins were minted in Caesar’s image, but human beings are created in God’s image. Only an ingrate would trade with Caesar’s money but refuse to pay taxes to mint the money. But our lives are God’s because God made us. While Caesar may have a claim on our dollars and cents, God has a claim on our whole selves. We have obligations to the state, but we can only meet those obligations in the context of obedience to God.
Totalitarian governments, which demand complete subservience from their people, are illegitimate, and Christians must resist them or be guilty of idolatry. Daniel going to the lion’s den rather than worshipping the statue of King Nebuchadnezzar is a biblical example. Dietrich Bonhoeffer’s participation in the plot to kill Hitler is a more recent example. Most governments are not totalitarian, however.
What if we object to how our taxes are spent? A 2024 poll showed that the National Park Service, the Post Office, and NASA are wildly popular. But the Departments of Education and Justice? Not so much. And yet, they wouldn’t be in the budget if there weren’t some taxpayers who support them. Paying taxes is a way we “bear with one another” (Eph. 4:2) in a democracy.
The least popular government agency is, not surprisingly, the IRS. No one likes to pay taxes, but Caesar does need revenue to move the mail, preserve Old Faithful, and fly N.C. State alum Christina Koch to the moon and back.
More than taxes, what Christians in America owe our government today is to “speak the truth in love” (Eph. 4:15) in the public square. Let us also “be quick to listen, slow to speak and slow to become angry” (Jas. 1:19), especially online. We should take advantage of all the peaceful means available to us to affect political change, for withdrawal from civic life fails to give Caesar his due as much as violence does. Finally, let us cultivate the spiritual fruit of patience when we don’t get our way.







