The Wisdom of a Presbyterian pastor patriot
Most Americans are Christians, but is America a Christian nation? Should it be? Christian Nationalism is a political movement that answers “Yes” to both those questions. Last weekend’s Rededicate 250 gathering in Washington DC is a good example of Christian Nationalism in action. Rededicate 250 brought thousands of people to the National Mall to sing, pray, and hear pastors and political leaders laud the nation’s Christian heritage. The gathering fell on the 250 th anniversary of a national “ Day of Humiliation, Fasting, and Prayer ” proclaimed by the Second Continental Congress at the outset of the American Revolution. Christian Nationalism has critics, many of whom are Christians. The Baptist Joint Committee on Religious Liberty, for example, argues that Christian Nationalism “distorts both the Christian faith and America’s constitutional democracy” by merging Christian and American identities. Why is Christian Nationalism a distortion of the Christian faith? To answer that question, let’s compare the 1776 proclamation, written by William Livingston, a Presbyterian delegate from New Jersey to the Continental Congress, to the invocation prayed by Speaker of the House Mike Johnson at the Rededicate 250 event. In view of the “insidious and vindictive” British administration, the Proclamation called all residents of the 13 colonies to acknowledge God’s providence over the current crisis, to confess their sins, and pray that the present danger might be averted. The proclamation urged Americans to fast and to forgo work on May 17 (a Friday that year) to gather in worship with Christians of all denominations. It further implored God to frustrate the plans of the British and turn them to “justice and benevolence.” But if that were not God’s will, the proclamation asked that God would grant the colonists victory on the battlefield, bless their leaders, and quickly restore America to peace, health, and plenty. Speaker Johnson’s invocation also interceded for our nation’s leaders, as well as soldiers, health care professionals, parents, and pastors. He also acknowledged, in far more muted tones than the 1776 proclamation, our collective shortcomings. “Father, we pray for mercy upon our land, mercy upon us for our mistakes.” But the Speaker’s prayer was really quite different than William Livingston’s resolution. Johnson did not call on the attendees to humble themselves. He claimed that the Rededicate 250 crowd was already humble because they viewed the nation’s victories as divine miracles. Johnson noted the rise of sinister voices that “insist that… the American story is one of hypocrisy and failure, and this story can only be understood through the lens of our sins. But Father, we reject that. We rebuke that.” The Continental Congress did not reject those sentiments at all! Its resolution spoke frankly about sin, not just the sins of an arrogant King across the Atlantic, but sin on this side of the Atlantic, which God was punishing by wielding an arrogant King against them. Speaker Johnson did not pray for his ideological enemies. He mentioned them only to condemn their viewpoints. While Livingston’s resolution strongly denounced British oppression, it called the British “our unnatural enemies.” War between Britain and America was not normal! It was fratricide. “We are inoculating the world with a mild form of Christianity, so that it is now practically immune against the real thing,” wrote E. Stanley Jones, missionary and theologian. That’s what Christian Nationalism does. Christian Nationalism uses Christian language, scripture and symbols to form self-congratulatory people. It asks nothing more of people than to look at the past through rose-colored glasses and feel confirmed in their low opinions of their present day opponents. It certainly doesn’t ask people to fast! Christian faith, on the other hand, calls people to turn their lives around and turn to God for help to be peaceful, virtuous, and courageous citizens who hope for reconciliation, even in the most bitter conflicts. And that call to transformation begins with Christians.
Society's lost sheep need a shepherd
Why not rejoice when others rejoice?
What Christians owe their governments
An unwise and unwarranted conflict
“April is the cruelest month,” wrote T.S. Eliot, but this February is giving April a run for its money. January’s snow and ice held on for weeks, and no sooner had it finally melted than a blizzard dumped a new foot of frozen stuff on us. But in defense of February, it has blessed us with more than snow and cold. We have gained an hour of daylight this month! Imagine how much worse you’d have felt if you’d had an hour’s less daylight on Monday to shovel all that snow. The lengthening of the days coincides with the Christian season of Lent. In fact, the word Lent comes from an old Germanic word for spring, langatin , the season in which the days grow longer. So, what is Lent? A season in the church when the sermons grow longer? Not necessarily. In the ancient church, candidates for conversion went through a period of study, prayer, and fasting to prepare for baptism, which often happened on Easter. By the fourth century, this pre-baptismal, pre-Easter “intensive” course in Christianity had grown to 40 days, inspired Jesus’s 40-day fast in the desert. At its best, Lent is about refocusing ourselves on the death and resurrection of Jesus, our own dying to sin and rising with Christ in baptism, and basic Christian spiritual disciplines. “Just as athletes need to drill key skills and musicians need to practice scales, so too Christians need to practice self-denial and self-giving love,” writes Belmont University’s John Witvliet. John Calvin, the 16th century Reformation leader, was a strong believer in fasting, prayer, and education, but not as it was practiced during Lent in his day and time. He believed that mandating annual observances of spiritual disciplines encouraged hypocrisy and spiritual pride. He wanted Christians to take up spiritual disciplines in response to their feelings of gratitude, not because the calendar said so. In recent decades, Presbyterians have reintegrated Lent into our worship life. We observe Ash Wednesday each year. In February and March, we hear passages of scripture that focus on our need for repentance and Christ’s suffering on the cross. Some Presbyterians give up things for Lent—everything from chocolate to social media. But we do well to remember Calvin’s concern about hypocrisy and pride. As Peter Bower has written , ashes on our foreheads are not there to show off our faith. They are there to remind us that we are going to die, and everything we cling to tightly we will one day relinquish. The ashes in the shape of a cross remind us that if we want to live for Christ, we must die with him. I applaud all efforts to give up sweets and social media, but there might be a deeper question to grapple with this time of year. What needs to die in you so that you may live forever with Christ? What needs to die in our church so that we may receive Christ’s resurrection power? How might you express your gratitude to God in concrete ways? In this season of lengthening days, how is the Spirit of God stretching you?
Before there was streaming, and before there was cable TV, there was ABC’s Wide World of Sports. If you wanted to watch athletes in lower profile events such as power lifting or skiing, you tuned into Wide World of Sports on Saturday afternoons. Each week the show began with the same tag line: “Spanning the globe to bring you the constant variety of sport... the thrill of victory... and the agony of defeat…” This year’s Winter Olympics have delivered plenty of thrills, and plenty of agony. When Norwegian skier Atle Lie McGrath threw away his ski poles and stomped off the course after missing a gate in the slalom final, I initially thought he was being a poor sport. Then the announcer informed me that McGrath’s grandfather had died on the opening day of the games. As the camera zoomed in on McGrath lying in a snowbank at the edge of the woods, my heart went out to him. My heart goes out to slalom gold medalist Mikaela Shiffrin in a different way. When she broke a 12-year drought in the Olympic slalom competition, Shiffrin stood motionless for a good long time. In 2020, Shiffrin’s father had died from injuries sustained in a fall. The skier told reporters that when she came across the finish line a winner, she felt at peace about her father’s absence for the first time, so she took a moment to be silent with him. These and other stories remind me of a fascinating Olympic story from a century ago that was brought to life in the 1981 film Chariots of Fire. The movie dramatizes the experiences of two British runners at the 1924 Paris games, Eric Liddell, a devout Scottish Christian, and Harold Abrahams, a Jewish Englishman. Abrahams must overcome prejudice to achieve his potential, while Liddell must allay his sister Jennie’s concerns that he is neglecting God’s call by pursuing a running career. (Liddell was born in China to missionary parents.) In a memorable scene , Liddell explains, “Jennie, you’ve got to understand. I believe that God made me for a purpose—for China—but he also made me fast! And when I run, I feel his pleasure. To give it up would be to hold him in contempt.” Liddell’s dream to win gold for Britain is seemingly thwarted when the 100-meter heats are scheduled for a Sunday. Despite pressure from the British Olympic Committee and the Prince of Wales himself, Liddell refuses to break the sabbath by competing. Another British competitor, having already medaled, gives up his place in the 400-meter race to Liddell. In the 400 final, held on a weekday, Liddell won gold, while Abrahams won gold in the 100. After the events memorialized in the movie, Liddell did return to China as a missionary. During World War II, he was interned in a Japanese concentration camp. In the camp, he won the respect of all the prisoners for his tireless efforts to serve them and ensure a just distribution of food and medicine. He died of malnutrition and a brain tumor five months before the camp was liberated. Liddell’s life witnesses to the Protestant belief that God can be glorified in secular life as much as in ordained or clerical ministries. Liddell also believed that the pursuit of a secular vocation should be governed by obedience to God’s commandments. Christian disagree about what should and should not be done on the sabbath, but then and now, people respect Liddell for not compromising his principles. As you watch the final events in this year’s Olympic games and witness new thrilling and agonizing tales spun on the ice and in the snow, remember Eric Liddell’s quote, and fill in the blanks for yourself: “I believe that God made me for a purpose, for _____, but he also made me _____! And when I _____, I feel his pleasure.” Complete those two sentences, and you’ll know without any doubt what your calling is. Image credit: By Alexandquan - Own work, CC BY-SA 4.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=91164821
While driving the other day, I heard WIP’s Hugh Douglas issue a warning to any women listening to his show: if your man wants to take you out for Valentine’s Day on Friday or Sunday, you aren’t his main event this weekend! Douglas then chuckled to himself as if he’d exposed the true colors of half the men in Philly. Valentine’s Day is a fraught holiday. If you are single or widowed but don’t want to be, the cards, chocolates, and roses for sale can make you feel judged or envious. Inflation and price gouging can make even happy couples feel bad about themselves on February 14. Eating out in general is much more expensive than it was before the pandemic, and restaurants markup prices for entrées by 20% to 50% on Valentine’s Day. So, let’s change the subject! Before Valentine’s Day was dedicated to romantic love, it was a day to remember a Christian martyr. But who? More than one Valentinus was persecuted for their faith. The biography of one such St. Valentine describes him as a Christian priest who was placed under house arrest but won over his judge by restoring the eyesight of the judge’s daughter. The judge and his whole household were baptized. Later, he was arrested for evangelizing and appeared before Emperor Claudius Gothicus. When Valentine pressed Claudius to convert, the emperor sentenced Valentine to death. He was beaten and beheaded on February 14, 269. The date and the saint gradually got associated with romantic love in the late Middle Ages and early modern period, thanks in part to the poetry of Geoffrey Chaucer and John Donne. There are many such stories of martyrs who healed in the name of Christ and boldly witnessed to him, even when threatened with death. Today, persecution is not a problem that American Christians face. It’s indifference. But our engagement with the world should still mirror the general pattern of the saints who’ve gone before us. Our words and our deeds should point away from ourselves and toward the one who suffered and rose from the dead to heal a broken world. Some, like Valentine’s judge, may come to faith; others, like Emperor Claudius, may not. This Valentine’s Day, whether you are single, married, divorced, or widowed, ask yourself three questions: With whom does Jesus Christ want me to talk about my experience of him? What good deed can I do that will glorify God? Can I leave the results of my witness up to God? Grace and peace to you, Marvin Image credit: Public domain reproduction of illuminated manuscript page, Germany, 14th-15th century.
Religion has taken center stage in the debate over immigration enforcement. Earlier this week, a reporter asked Speaker of the House Mike Johnson to respond criticisms that Pope Leo XIV made of the Trump administration’s immigration policy. You can watch Pope Leo’s comments here , and Speaker Johnson’s reply here . The Pope urged the authorities to respect the religious freedoms of detainees and allow religious workers to visit them while in detention. Citing Matthew 25, the Pope noted that when we meet our Maker, we will have to answer the question, “How did you receive the foreigner?” He called for deep reflection on what’s happening in the United States, especially with respect to people who have lived in the country for years without causing problems. The Speaker countered that borders are biblical. Immigrants should be welcomed and loved, but the command to love one’s neighbor applies to individuals, not to the government. The role of the state is to maintain order and bring wrath on the wrongdoer, he said, citing Romans 13. He argued that we should uphold sovereign borders out of love for those inside the border, not hatred for those outside. I appreciate the Speaker’s attempt to think through a thorny public policy matter from a biblical and theological viewpoint. But the Pope has the better of the argument. ICE and CBP officers are not executing wrath on wrongdoers alone. They are harassing, detaining, and even killing U.S. citizens, non-citizens who are in the country legally, and people whose only wrong is being in the country without documentation, which is a civil, not a criminal offense. In fact, the Bible holds the civil authority as well as individuals to a high standard of neighborly love. One of many examples is when the prophet Jeremiah declared to the King, “Thus says the Lord: Act with justice and righteousness and deliver from the hand of the oppressor anyone who has been robbed. And do no wrong or violence to the alien, the orphan, and the widow, or shed innocent blood in this place.” Borders and boundaries are necessary to maintain the integrity of any entity, but sound borders are semi-permeable. Cellular membranes allow nutrients in, waste to go out, and cells to communicate with each other. Family boundaries are rather tight, but even families admit individuals from the outside. If we only married our closest kin, that would be disastrous! National borders exist to keep invading armies out while allowing trade, tourists, and immigrants to move between nations. In the book of Ruth, when a famine broke out in Bethlehem, an Israelite family crossed the border into Moab looking for food. When the famine ended, some of them returned along with a Moabite woman named Ruth. She became the great-grandmother of King David. If the border between Israel and Moab had been less porous, Israel’s history and ours might have turned out very differently. There are many details about immigration policy that can’t be read straight off the pages of Bible, such as how many refugees to admit every year, or how to reform the byzantine regulations governing the issuance of visas. But here is my list of first principles that I think all people of goodwill should ascribe to: State wrath should target only the wrathful and should be deployed sparingly. God calls the civil authority to a positive mission of protecting the vulnerable, and that includes the foreigner and their religious liberty and economic welfare. The immigrant is Jesus Christ in disguise. Immigrants should be welcomed as the spiritual and material blessings they are. Prudence should dictate the finer points of immigration policy, not fear or resentment. Yours in Christ, Marvin Photo credit: Rio Grande Bend near Boquillas Canyon (Big Bend National Park, TX), author Glysiak
